Court News

TSC CEO Cheptumo Ayabei’s Appointment Challenged in Court

Exterior of the Teachers Service Commission headquarters in Kenya.
The Teachers Service Commission is facing a fresh court challenge over the appointment of its new Secretary and CEO.

The appointment of Cheptumo Ayabei as the Teachers Service Commission (TSC) Secretary and Chief Executive Officer has been challenged in the High Court over alleged irregularities in the recruitment process.

The petition, filed by Fredrick Bikeri, accuses the commission of violating constitutional and statutory requirements governing competitive public appointments, arguing that the exercise lacked transparency, fairness and accountability.

Bikeri wants the court to declare Ayabei’s appointment unlawful, unconstitutional, null and void, and order TSC to conduct a fresh recruitment exercise in accordance with the Constitution and applicable laws.

ALSO READ

In an urgent application filed alongside the petition, he is seeking conservatory orders barring Ayabei from assuming, occupying or exercising the powers and functions of the office pending the hearing and determination of the case.

He is also asking the court to suspend the implementation of the appointment and restrain TSC commissioners, officers and employees from recognising or facilitating Ayabei’s assumption of office.

At the centre of the dispute is the recruitment exercise that began on September 29, 2026, when TSC advertised the vacancy and invited applications for the position of Commission Secretary and CEO.

According to the petition, the vacancy attracted 124 applications, but only five candidates were shortlisted for interviews.

The petitioner argues that the commission failed to disclose the criteria and benchmarks used to shortlist the candidates, raising questions about whether the process was conducted objectively and in accordance with the requirements outlined in the advertisement.

He further claims that the interview schedule, which had been publicly communicated on November 7, 2026, was subsequently altered without prior notice to affected candidates or a reasonable explanation.

The interviews were initially scheduled to begin at 9am on November 16, 2026. Bikeri alleges that changes to the schedule disrupted the process, created uncertainty among candidates and potentially gave some applicants an unfair advantage.

The petitioner also questions the order in which candidates were interviewed, claiming that the circumstances surrounding the exercise raised concerns about whether the outcome had been predetermined in Ayabei’s favour.

He further raises allegations that Ayabei had occupied or begun performing functions of the office before his formal appointment, arguing that this casts doubt on whether the recruitment was genuinely competitive.

Bikeri contends that the alleged irregularities violated Article 10 of the Constitution, which provides for transparency, accountability, integrity, good governance and the rule of law.

He also cites Article 47 on fair administrative action, Article 27 on equality and Article 232, which outlines the values and principles of public service, including fair competition and merit-based appointments.

The petitioner further relies on Section 16 of the Teachers Service Commission Act, 2012, which provides for competitive recruitment and appointment of the Commission Secretary.

In addition to challenging the appointment, Bikeri wants the court to compel TSC to produce the complete recruitment records, including the shortlisting criteria, candidates’ scores, interview evaluation matrix, interview schedules and final recruitment report.

He argues that the documents are necessary to establish how the five candidates were shortlisted, evaluated and assessed before Ayabei was selected.

The petitioner maintains that suspending the appointment would not disrupt the commission’s operations, claiming that an acting Secretary/CEO is available to discharge the responsibilities of the office while the case is pending.

TSC, however, has defended the recruitment process, maintaining that it was conducted transparently and in accordance with the law. The commission has said Ayabei emerged as the best candidate among the five shortlisted applicants following interviews held on November 16, 2026, and that his appointment took effect on the same day.

The commission has also explained that the fresh recruitment followed earlier court interventions that halted the previous exercise and eventually required it to restart the process.

The latest petition now places Ayabei’s appointment under fresh judicial scrutiny, with the court being asked to determine whether TSC complied with constitutional and statutory requirements governing public appointments.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE

Facebook WhatsApp Telegram X